Skip to main content
  • 2020 Annual Report
  • Decision and Next Steps in New York Elephant Rights Case
  • Help #FreeMinnie
  • NhRP Seminar Series
  • NhRP Interview Series
  • Laurence Tribe: “It’s time to bring elephants into the circle of rightsholders”
<
>
Blog

Back to nonhumanrights.org

  • Donate

Back to nonhumanrights.org

  • About NhRP
    • Meet the Team
    • FAQ
    • Media Center
    • Contact Us
  • Our Work
    • Litigation
    • Legislation + Advocacy
    • Education
  • Progress
  • Blog
Photo: Animal Defenders International

Cases

Update: Beulah, Karen, and Minnie Elephant Rights Lawsuit

By Lauren Choplin on December 28, 2017
Share this story:

Today we issued the following statement from NhRP President Steven M. Wise on the Connecticut Superior Court’s dismissal of our petition for a common law writ of habeas corpus on behalf of three elephants (Minnie, Beulah, and Karen) at the Commerford Zoo in Goshen, CT:

“The Superior Court gave two grounds for its dismissal. The first was the NhRP lacked standing. While we pointed out that, as far back as the days of human slavery, the Connecticut courts have allowed any petitioner to seek a common law writ of habeas corpus on behalf of a detained individual, the Superior Court in our case added the further requirement that the petitioner filing the lawsuit have a ‘significant relationship’ with the detainee, unless a detainee has no significant relationships at all, and that the NhRP failed to allege the elephants have no significant relationships at all. The NhRP had thought it plain that the three elephants have no significant relationships with any petitioner able to file a habeas corpus lawsuit on their behalf against their captors. We are also concerned that the Superior Court in its decision inappropriately analogized their captors at the Commerford Zoo to the elephants’ parents. In each of its prior common law habeas corpus cases in which a court addressed standing, the NhRP has always been found to have standing. We are optimistic we will eventually be found to have standing in this case as well.

The second ground for dismissal was that the Superior Court found the lawsuit to be frivolous because no one had ever brought such a case before in Connecticut. We believe the court failed to consider the manner in which the common law has traditionally changed over the last 800 years. Each of the thousands of common law rules that exist today once did not exist. Each common law rule that exists today was once the subject of the first such case to be brought. In short, there is an important difference between a frivolous case and a novel one. That said we are studying the decision and will likely either seek to amend our habeas corpus petition to add a sentence stating that Minnie, Karen, and Beulah have no significant relationships with anyone able to to file a habeas corpus action against their captors or we will refile our lawsuit so that our petition includes this sentence. Should we be unsuccessful we will, of course, appeal.”

The judge’s comment concerning the lack of the allegation of the elephants’ significant relationship to which Steve refers is in footnote three in the Dec. 26, 2017 decision by Judge James Bentivegna.

To learn more about Beulah, Karen, and Minnie, visit their court case page. To help raise awareness of the world’s first elephant rights lawsuit, visit our #RumbleForRights Online Activist Toolkit.

Lauren is the NhRP’s Communications Director. She heads up internal and external communications, coordinating media coverage of our legal and policy work and managing our blog and social media pages.

Must Reads

  • Nonhuman Rights in Colombia: An Interview with Luis Domingo Gómez Maldonado in Interviews
  • Why Happy needs and deserves sanctuary in Campaigns, Cases
  • The Need for Chimpanzee Rights in Stories
  • Building An International Nonhuman Rights Movement in Collaborations
  • Upholding Fundamental Values and Principles of Justice in Stories
  • NhRP Addresses Highest Court in Colombia in Chucho Bear Rights Case in News

Get Involved

Subscribe to our email list to receive updates and learn about events and volunteer opportunities in your area.

Nonhuman Rights Project

We are the only civil rights organization in the United States dedicated solely to securing rights for nonhuman animals.

Sign up to receive updates

© 2021 Nonhuman Rights Project, all rights reserved.

  • Privacy

Follow us to get updates